Boundary-First Publishing Decisions, July 17, 2026
Internal staff QA index for the boundary-first decisions locked on 2026-07-17. 2 consumer pages passed Publish. Sections below record final Fold and Drop results, plus remaining Hold, Review, Validation, and Proof rows. Clean live URLs only. Theme sync targets live theme 150860365964. Do not append preview query params. Not in public nav or Guides menu.
Theme source outputs meta name robots content noindex, follow for handle boundary-first-20260717-live-proof via theme.liquid.
Today's new pages
Staff only. Robots: noindex, follow. Clean live URLs. Live theme 150860365964.
| Page | Type / hub | Suffix | Live URL | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Weather Radio |
Phase 1 spoke |
weather-radio-guide-links |
Open for QA |
Live 2026-07-17 |
|
Water Leak Detector |
Phase 1 spoke |
leak-detector-guide-links |
Open for QA |
Live 2026-07-17 |
Staff only. Do not link this index from public nav.
Publish
Passed every Phase 1 gate and is live. Open the clean URL to verify.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Weather Radio |
Published |
Gate passed. Owned by Monitoring & Emergency Preparedness. |
Open published page |
|
Water Leak Detector |
Published |
Gate passed. Owned by Smart Home & Safety Technology. |
Open published page |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Published in Phase 2
Published on 2026-07-17 after source-mapped drafting, FDA claim review, unique heroes, metafields, and live-URL QA. Pulse Oximeter is surfaced from approved discovery links. Home Thermometers remains live but unsurfaced pending separate discovery approval. Both stay outside global Guides navigation.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Pulse Oximeter |
Published and surfaced |
Device-specific fingertip oximeter buying and setup guide, distinct from Vitals Monitoring. Live at /pages/pulse-oximeter-guide and linked from the Monitoring overview and Vitals Monitoring. Not in Guides nav. |
Verify live canonical |
|
Home Thermometers |
Published, live review passed |
Retargeted from the mismatched finger-thermometer packet. Live at /pages/thermometer-guide with a unique hero and clean desktop/mobile review. Discovery links are still off; not in Guides nav. |
Verify live canonical |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Hold
Still unpublished after triage. Needs ownership, keyword, or clinical-claim evidence before any Publish decision.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Home Security System |
Hold for differentiation |
Whole-system boundary is defensible around contracts, monitoring, outage backup, installation, response workflow, and privacy. Keyword intent and service scope remain uncleared. |
Verify topic owner |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Fold
Final Fold. Do not publish as a separate page. Verify the live canonical that owns the intent.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Pill Dispenser |
Fold |
Manual organization tools already owned by Medication Organization. Automated devices stay on Smart Home Validation. |
Verify canonical |
|
Medical ID Bracelet |
Fold |
Tracking & ID already covers bracelets and ID planning. |
Verify canonical |
|
Personal Emergency Response System |
Fold |
PERS is a terminology variant of Medical Alert Systems. |
Verify canonical |
|
Smartwatch Fall Detection |
Fold |
Fall Detection Wearable already covers watches, bands, alerts, charging, and testing. |
Verify canonical |
|
Sensors |
Fold |
Broad Sensors proposal duplicates Safety Devices connected-sensor scope. |
Verify canonical |
|
Motion Sensors |
Fold |
Lighting owns motion-sensor lighting; residual connected-sensor intent stays with Safety Devices. |
Verify canonical |
|
Doorbell Camera for Seniors |
Fold |
Video Doorbells owns doorbell-camera workflows. Outdoor keeps porch cross-links only. |
Verify canonical |
|
Smart Smoke Detector |
Fold |
Detector intent is already owned by Home Safety Detectors. |
Verify canonical |
|
Smart Carbon Monoxide Detector |
Fold |
Detector intent is already owned by Home Safety Detectors. |
Verify canonical |
|
Doorbell Camera |
Fold |
Video Doorbells already owns selection, alerts, storage, privacy, power, and maintenance. |
Verify canonical |
|
Caregiver Alert System |
Fold |
Caregiver Alerts already owns connected notifications and escalation planning. |
Verify canonical |
|
Outdoor Slip Prevention |
Fold |
Outdoor snow, ice, and walkway coverage owns this intent. |
Verify topic owner |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Drop
Drop the current proposal. Any related detector material stays with the live detectors guide. A true first-aid page would need fresh Validation work.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
First Aid |
Drop current proposal |
Packet keyword and brief are First Alert smoke/CO pollution, not first-aid intent. |
Verify detector owner |
|
Medication Management |
Drop current proposal |
Medication management is primarily clinical and pharmacist-led. Household tools stay with Medication Organization. |
Verify live canonical |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Review
Still unpublished. Review requires an editorial and ownership decision before a publish gate can open.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Voice Assistants |
Review required |
Accessibility and privacy boundary is defensible with FCC/CISA sources, but keyword, title, and packet still need coordinated retargeting. |
Verify topic owner |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Validation
Still unpublished. Validation requires corrected evidence or packet inputs, not page drafting.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Automated Medication Dispenser |
Validation required |
Smart Home ownership and a safety boundary are resolved. The polluted keyword and generic packet still block Publish. |
Verify organizer boundary |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.
Proof
Internal QA pages remain noindex and outside public navigation, related guides, and normal content counts.
| Proposed page | Decision | Reason / unblock rule | Verification |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Live proof pages |
Intentional proof |
Keep internal QA indexes separate from consumer pathways. This dated index is the verification entry point. |
Open this QA index |
Staff decision record. Unpublished handles must not be added to public navigation.